Friday, October 28, 2016

Stereotyping and American Indians


In filmmaking, framing is the process by which filmmakers or, if you want to get technical, cinematographers determine what will appear in a shot. Framing includes angles, sizes, and shot compositions. Framing can be used to keep a viewer’s focus on an object or objects, to direct attention back to a particular scene, and so much more. All of this is done to tell a story. Filmmakers use framing to enhance how they tell their stories. If you think about it though, frames turn what can be seen as a relatively ‘infinite’ view of an object or a scene into a finite or limited view. What we see and how we see it is determined by the filmmakers. Framing Theory, as I see it, isn’t much different from a framing definition in film/video. ‘Framing’ can be seen as a perspective, an interpretation, a certain view or perception of the world/reality. Frames help us interpret the world around us. They also help us present that world to others. These frames are built upon our beliefs, values, and experiences which are derived from our “reciprocal interactions among individuals, social groups, and cultural products”—through communication. Three stages of framing are identified: mental framing, group framing, and content framing (as cited in Miller & Ross, 2004) Mental framing is what happens in us. It’s our perceptions and interpretations of reality. It’s our evaluations, organizations,  internalizations etc of external frames. Group framing is exactly what the name implies, the frames of the group or society. Group frames are a principal part of a  group’s shared culture. Content frames are the cultural products that a group produces (Miller & Ross, 2004). Through content frames groups and individuals (mental) present there view of reality. 
Miller and Ross (2004) discuss content frames that have been historically prevalent throughout the media as it relates to Native Americans. These frames portray Native/Indian Americans as degraded, bad/good, generic, and as “other.” The “degraded” Indian is portrayed as poor, pitiful, and a drunk. They can also be shown as corrupt, the casino Indian trope is proof of that (Lacroix, 2001). The “bad/good” Indian frame depicts Native Americans as either ‘good’—friendly, noble, wise, respectful of nature, subservient to Anglo-European culture—or ‘bad’—savages, violent, evil. The “generic’ Indian frames portrays Native Americans as just that, Native Americans. It lumps all Native Americans under one category. It generalizes, and as a result,  dismisses differences in languages, values, beliefs practices and even physical features among the various Native American tribes. It would be like categorizing all people from the caribbean as ‘caribbean’ without taking into account all different caribbean islands there are out there. The Indian as “other” promotes an us vs them mentality. The historic relic frame depicts Native American as stuck in the past. Native mercian are reduced to icons and are seen as incapable of adapting to modern times. These frames can make Native Americans seem inferior, and uncultured. If a person doesn’t know better, they just might find themselves perceiving Native Americans as they are portrayed in the Media. These frames, or stereotypes if you may, can influence a child’s cultural Identity. Not only can they effect how people see others, but how others see themselves. Stereotype treat is one such example of how stereotypes can effect someone’s cultural identity. It’s so easy to get caught up in these stereotypes when your constantly bombarded with images of what other people think you are. It makes you wonder if any of these stereotypes of frames—the lazy, drunken, degraded Indian—actually help contribute to the high rates of alcoholism, unemployment, and death on the reservations.   
Is it justifiable for a person from one culture to encourage a person from another culture to disregard his or her own cultural values? Is there an easy answer for this question? Is there an answer that everyone can agree on? I can say no. It’s not justifiable. I can tell you how important it is to respect someone else’s culture and how wrong it is to evaluate someone else’s culture according to the standards of your own. But what about cultural values that uplift certain members of society while systematically exploiting and oppressing others. Would that be reason enough to disregard certain cultural values? I believe that there is right and wrong. One could argue that It is a persons culture or society that determines what is right and wrong, you know moral relativism and all that jazz. While I do believe that societies determine what is right and wrong, I also think in absolutes. I believe that there are values or (moral) principles out there that are or should be regarded as universally valid. So, is it justifiable for a person from one culture to encourage a person from another cultures to disregard his or her own cultural values? I believe the answer is yes, if that person’s cultural values infringe upon basic human rights. I feel like as a christian, I should have yet another justification, but I don’t have the energy to get into it.     
A few years ago my class and I went on a study tour to Peru. We we’re on Lake Titicaca in Puno, Peru, when one of my classmates, turned to me, scrunched up her nose, and said “how can they live like this?” I was a bit annoyed that she had said that. I thought, “maybe they would say the same about us If they saw the way we lived.” I didn’t tell her that though. I didn’t say anything. I just ignored her and did as If I hadn’t heard what she said. Looking back, I wish I had said something. I wish I had shared my thoughts, shared what I had learned. I believe that’s an important aspect of being a diversity ally, sharing what you’ve learned with others especially ignorant others.

Lacroix, C. L. (2011) High stakes stereotypes: The emergence of the “Casino Indian” trope in television depictions of contemporary Native American. The Howard Journal of Communications, 22, 1-23.
Miller, E., & Ross, D. S. (2004) They are not us: Framing of American Indians by the Boston Globe. The Howard Journal of Communications, 15, 245-259. 


Wednesday, October 12, 2016

Cultural History


I identify as christian—more specifically a Seventh-day Adventist Christian. As a Christian I believe that there is life after death. If you’ve accepted Christ you’ll be united  with him and your loved ones (who’ve also accepted him) in heaven. You’ll have eternal life. If you don’t accept Christ you’ll be subjected to hell’s fire, die and be eternally separated from God. As a Seventh-day Adventist Christian, while I do believe in the afterlife, I’m convinced that once your dead your dead. There’s no thinking, feeling, nothing. I believe you’ll stay dead until Christ comes. This is completely different to Hindu and Buddhist religious traditions. Hindus believe that the soul is immortal and it is this soul that is reincarnated at death. Because of this Hindus learn not to fear or grieve over the death of loved ones. Buddhist believe death to be certain but temporary. A persons deeds, be they good or bad, determines how many times they are reborn. Once they have enough good Karma, the person will experience nirvana—a state that releases a person from all unhappiness. Most religions, including my own, hold that one should avoid death. Very sick people should just keep on fighting. Buddhists on the other hand rejects this idea. Death is seen as time to be at peace with oneself and the universe. The state of mind at death is determinant of rebirth. The Jewish religion maintains that death is unnatural process. It teaches that life on earth should be cherished. It focuses on living an on earthly  life as opposed to an afterlife. Although, Jewish theology with Christianity, and Islam (with some dissimilarities) include Judgement Day when all people will be resurrected to be judged by God for their beliefs/deeds.  The Islam tradition holds that after death paradise awaits those who  have submitted to God’s will while Hell is reserved for those who haven’t.  Death in the name of Allah guarantees a persons spot in paradise. Those who engage in suicide bombing believe their actions will be awarded in paradise.        

Most would agree that our attitudes and behaviors are influenced by our past experiences.  Our past directly influences our present. In order to understand ourselves we need to be aware our past.  Sure, we shouldn’t allow are past to dictate our present but we are, at least to an extent, a product of our past. In my opinion, that’s the role national history plays in shaping national identity. History incorporates our sense of community, geography, economic and political  processes, governmental procedures, and key historical figures. These factors come together to give people  of a culture their identity (Samovar; Porter; McDaniel; Roy, 2016). A nation’s history helps to explain contemporary values, beliefs, traditions, and institutions guiding that nation. A nation’s history helps to explain its identity. Take for example the United States and its reputation of being “the land of the free.”  The early immigrants common desire to be free of oppressive governance, and authoritarian religious practices led to  a the unalienable rights of “life, liberty, and the pursuit of happiness,” and the separation of church and state. 

Obviously a culture’s history can help explain its values, beliefs, and actions.  Our past can help shape our present. Past events, along the line, may also have negative effects on the present. Some historical legacies of the U.S. and other countries have produced discord and conflict. For example, Muslims and Hindus were at odds ever since early Muslim raiders “set about conquering the Hindus and destroying their temples” (p. 182).  After  India’s independence the conflict between Hindus and Muslims led to the partitioning of India into India and Pakistan. The partition brought with it extensive political violence between Hindus and Muslims. This long lasting hostility between India and Pakistan and the “continuing territorial conflict over the kashmir region is a legacy of the partition”(p. 183).   The legacy of Manifest Destiny—the belief that U.S. expansion across the American continents was justified and inevitable—can be seen by the United State’s call for political/democratic reforms in other nations. The invasion of Iraq and Afghanistan spring to mind. One could argue, to an extent, that it is the United State’s continued application of Manifest Destiny that led to the destabilization in the middle east and allowed groups like ISIS to obtain power.   

Clark’s four stages of minority representations in the media are “Non-recognition,” “Ridicule,” “Regulation,” and “Respect.” Clark’s model was developed to be applied to representations of African Americans in the media. I do believe that these stages are still applicable in the media today especially when applied to depictions of African Americans and Native Americans in the media. However, it’s not certain wether these stages can be applied to other minorities in the U.S. That needs to be tested. 

Also, if applying Clark’s model today some changes should probably be made. Clarke’s does not take into account token characters (the token black friend is such a common trope), and the aggressive/violent black person stereotype. 

Friday, September 23, 2016

Lessons From The Family



My grandfather, Darrel Duggins, and my grandmother, Ilsa Roosberg, were married on June 13, 1962. They had 7 kids--3 girls and 4 boys. My mother, Louise Duggins, was the first of the seven.
My mom and father were married in early December and out of this Union 3 kids were born--Michael, N'kili (Me), and Kareem.

When I think of culture I think art, dress, traditions, tangible objects or behaviors—things that you can see that are obviously different from others.  What’s interesting though is that much of culture is actually invisible.
Much of our learning of culture occurs subconsciously. We are rarely aware of the cultural messages we receive. They are so subtle that we hardly notice these messages and lessons coming in or acted out. Most of the time it takes exposure to another culture to realize what has occurred. For example people on my island are extremely nosey. Which probably makes me nosey too but I hadn’t realized that until I started living in the United States. I remember during my freshman year of college I was sitting in my room with my roommate and her friends. At that time, my roommate’s friends and I had been mere acquaintances. They were talking and you could say I was eavesdropping but in my mind I was a part of the conversation. Why else would they speak so loudly if they didn’t want me to hear? The conversation changed to gossip. They were talking about someone and I had missed their name. It was really juicy and they had gotten really animated. I really wanted to know who they were talking about so reflexively I blurted out, “who are you talking about?” They looked at me strangely, like they had forgotten I was in the room and like it wasn’t any of my business. I guess it wasn’t but back on my island I wouldn’t have gotten such a reaction regardless if they were acquaintances or friends.


Globalization, in terms of family, has its advantages, such as creating job opportunities and an increase in cultural awareness and it also has its draw backs. Workers leave their families and move from one country to another in order to seek jobs or higher pay in order to support their families. This in return changes family structure and dynamics. Stress is placed on parents, children, and other family members. And in some cases families are split up due to parents not being legal citizens leaving children behind. 

On my island I have seen globalization in action. With the creation of our oil terminals, men from different parts of the world were hired. With the extra men on the island a whore house (we call it the Nest) was established. Women from different countries were hired to work there. The local men were also participating at The Nest. It got so in depth that many local men left their wives to pursue relationships with these women. As a result their families were broken up. However, there was some good that came out of it. Many of the women working at the Nest had left their families behind.  The men that left their wives married the women and  this provided  them with the means  to bring their families to the island. 

When parents adopt a child trans-culturally, assimilation into the new culture is necessary. I believe that will occur without much conscious effort. It is the parent’s responsibility to ensure that the child has contact and knowledge of his or her birth culture. Children of trans-cultural adoptions tend to either feel “separate from” or “apart of.”  Without a connection to their own roots these kids may feel separate from families or friends that look different than they do.  They may also feel separate from people who look like they do and share’s their cultural background but who they ultimately feel no connection to because of their lack of knowledge and contact with their own culture. Parents, who ensure that their child has contact and knowledge of his or her culture helps them develop a sense of identity. 

Friday, September 9, 2016

The Nature of Cultural Identity







I was born on the island of St. Maarten. The place known for its French and Dutch Nationalities as well as being THE best place to be  blown away by airplanes. Literally. 




When I was 2 years old my maternal grandfather died. As a result my family relocated to St. Eustatius so my mom could run the family business and that's where I've lived  for most of my life. St. Eustatius, most people have never heard of it and with  good reason.  With an estimated population of only 3500-4000 people and an area of roughly 11 square miles we're a really small island. 
St. Eustatius, affectionately known as Statia,  is a special municipality of the Netherlands. So there are Dutch influences on our islands culture such as language--Dutch is our official language--and customs.  The American, Surinamese, Guyanese, and Dominican Republic influences also make for an interesting cultural mix. 
Family is pretty big here. Like really big. Its not just the nuclear family. When we say family we’re referring  to  grandmothers, grandfathers, (great) uncles and (great) aunts, and cousins that are more like siblings than anything else. And that doesn't begin to cover the endless uncles and aunts that aren't really uncles and aunts but are really close family friends that you’ve grown up with. On Statia there is no such thing as an extended family it’s just family. So you can imagine I grew up in a full house. When my aunt got married and moved out she built a house directly across from us. She basically lives in our back yard. So does my great uncle by the way. Currently most of my aunts and uncles live on neighboring islands. With my brother and I away for school its a pretty empty house. But every Christmas we all travel back home to Statia and we spend the holiday together. Its one of my favorite traditions, seeing family members that I haven't seen for the entire year. 
I graduated from high school in 2010. I chose to further my education in the U.S. Studying in the United States, for 4 years, has been quite the experience especially considering where I come from— a very small island to a big country. Luckily attending Andrews University with it’s small and tight-knit community reminded me of back home. However, I still had to adjust. For example, on my island walking into a room or passing someone on the road and not greeting them is the ultimate sin. Even if you see them 50 times a day, which is highly probable considering how small the island is, you need to acknowledge them each time. Lets just say I caught on very quickly that doing so while living here makes me seem kind of crazy, if some of the looks I’ve gotten are anything go by. Studying at Andrews University has taught me more to be culturally aware. It’s made me more independent something that I never really experienced at home. 
I have many Identities. I am a Statian. I am Dutch. I am a Gumbs (my father’s surname) and a Duggins (my mother’s surname). The name Duggins carries a big weight on Statia. My family’s business, Duggins Shopping Center is the largest grocery and department store on the island. On the island, If on the odd chance I have to explain myself to someone who may not know me, I just tell them my mother’s last name and they automatically know who I am. I guess in a way a large part of my Identity lies within my Family.  
What is Cultural Identity? Well to put it simply cultural Identity is the culture you identify with. It’s your membership in a group and it’s just one of your many Identities. It’s formed through communication. It’s something that’s learnt. A rigid adherence to the culture of our youth is not feasible. Culture itself is always changing, so I believe cultural identity in its pure from is not possible.  Much of our learning of culture is done subconsciously. So its likely that we wont be aware of certain shifts within our cultural identity until it has already occurred and sometimes we’re not aware even then.
The United States is becoming a “minority majority” nation. Because of this the United States’ dominant cultural values and those of minorities will integrate. 
Someone watching The Big Bang Theory may conclude that the United States is a diverse country and the people, though accepting, may be ignorant and sometimes a bit racist.  
 Based on lustig & Koester’s Stages in the development of cultural identity I believe I have Achieved my Cultural Identity. I know what it means to be a Statian. I am proud of who I am.

Friday, August 26, 2016

What's in a Name?

My aunt once told me that during the month of July in 1992, she was walking in Brooklyn, New York and stopped to check the books of a black vendor that was selling African books.  One of the books was about a little black girl from Nigeria of the IBO tribe, and her name was Nkili.  The book revealed that meaning of the name was “my skin is beautiful”.  When my Aunt explained the meaning of the name to my family it was unanimously decided that, N’kili would be my name. I’ve never come across anyone with my name and I’ve always took pleasure in that fact. It made me feel special. In a class where there would be many Deshanees or Michaels or countless variations thereof. I was the only N’kili. Though, that usually came and still comes with me having to hear many variants of my name and constantly having to  correct mispronunciations. In any such case it usually ends with me saying, “N’kili…but you can call me Kelly.” 
I’ve been called Kelly for as long as I can remember. Most people at home know me as such. My friends, my family they all call me Kelly. In fact, I mostly hear them call me N’kili when I’m in trouble, being yelled at,  or being called for. “Kelly” is the name I share with people when I see them struggling to pronounce my given name, N’kili. Its usually the name I share first when introducing myself to someone I know I probably will never see again or that will never get to know the real me.  Why exert the energy of instructing someone how to pronounce my name when I know they probably won’t use it again. 
My name Kelly has left me with no shortage of pet names. I have been affectionately called Kel, Kellbell, Kellchy, Kelchy-ann and Kelly-ann.  Interesting variations of N’kili such as Kili, and Nikibell has also been used by close friends and family. 
As a teacher its extremely important to learn the names of your students. Names are a part of one's identity and by leaving that vital part out you are essentially leaving out part of the individual. Names help create bonds and bonds are obviously important to create an ideal learning environment.
I knows what is like for a teacher to mispronounce your name. I know how frustrating it can be. It’s very satisfying when teachers put in the effort to learn your name no matter how embarrassing it may initially be for them. I remember dropping by my professor’s office one afternoon to ask him a question and before I could even ask my question he asked my how I pronounced my name I told him and then I listened to him struggle to do so. I felt sorry for him so I stated, “you can just call me Kelly.” He looked at me, smiled, and said, “that’s not your real name I want to learn how to pronounce your name. I think it’s beautiful.” Him saying that pretty much brightened my entire week. He was making an effort. It showed that he cared and that he wanted to get to know me—the real me.    

Teachers should get to know their students. They should refrain from making assumptions. It’s important to ask questions no matter how simple to avoid misunderstandings. Everyone has probably acted in ignorance at one time or the other. It’s something we’ve all experienced. Though ignorance may “prevent people from behaving according to the highest order of integrity, honor, knowledge, and wisdom,” It can still be educated.